Based on the gathered knowledge and evaluations from the pilot projects that were carried through in the SHE4AHA project, a general experience is that results are better, when an external facilitator is connected to a strategic change and implementation process. The reasons for this are manyfold, and among others;
1) A school manager is part of the school culture and risks either not see the critical factors or have difficulties to mobilize change because of the hierarchy or biased understandings from both the management side and stakeholder side.
2) If a staff member, or a group of staff members, are appointed facilitators, he / she / they risk(s) to be caught between two “camps” and a risk for creating internal “policy battles” is there.
3) An external facilitator is not part of the culture and will be able to see things from the “outside” without a biased understanding.
4) An external facilitator will be able to ask the difficult questions without prejudice.
5) Available time to make comprehensive follow-up on decisions and agreed actions is extremely important, and teachers or other staff members will very often not have this time available. Their primary job will normally be to provide teaching, and facilitation will be an additional task, hence the application of the health promoting school approach risks losing the momentum, if follow up does not take place in an effective way.
6) As a school manager it is easier to describe a concrete task to a contracted and external facilitator, keeping that person responsible for the process as described in a contract.
7) And perhaps most important of all: By using an external facilitator, school management is exempt from obligations as being responsible for the process, enabling school management to focus on the end product, namely to implement health promoting practices in the school environment. In other words, this construction and distribution of responsibility with an external facilitator creates ‘free space” for school management to engage in the process.
If a school decides not to engage an external facilitator to assist the change and implementation process, we strongly advise designating an internal coordinator for the task, providing this person sufficient time, resources and authority to complete the process. Still, it will be most helpful and relevant for this person to collaborate with an external school consultant or facilitator.